Messing with iTunes 8
Tuesday, September 9, 2008
That said, I still keep it installed for the simple fact it is a necessary evil in order to properly use two of my favorite devices, my iPod Classic and iPhone. So of course when iTunes 8 hit, I had to get it up and running to see if they fixed any of my gripes.
Of course they didn't.
Instead they put in more bloat and more features that arguably don't make the already abysmal experience any better for me.
New feature number one: The Genius Sidebar. I can see this being useful for the people that actually buy music through the iTunes store. It shows the top albums from the current artist, a list of songs from the artist that don't exist in your library, and a list of related artists. Just one problem: It doesn't work. The Top Albums are completely arbitrary, the Related Artists are only loosely related on a genre level (which I hate to begin with) and the Missing Tracks section doesn't function at all. When I select a Less Than Jake song, it lists five songs that I'm supposedly missing, but they're right there in my library.
New feature number two: Genius Playlists. Besides the scariness of Apple having full access to my playlists and media library, I gave this a shot to see if it worked at all. The information gathering process took forty-five minutes or so to pull from my entire iTunes library (Which in itself isn't even my full library, only the stuff that I can easily get album covers for. I'm pretty anal when it comes to everything on my iPod having cover art.). I don't know exactly how their algorithm works, but it seemed slightly better than the randomness of party shuffle. At least it didn't throw in a bunch of metal when I picked out a Radiohead song.New feature number three: Grid View. This, I can appreciate. Cover flow is nice eye candy, but rather sub-optimal for actually finding stuff. List view is great, but it can get boring. Why am I even getting cover art if it doesn't use it? So grid view is a pretty good thing to me.
![]() | ![]() |
My conclusion? Much like the App Store's iTunes controller before it, a good app isn't going to make me use iTunes because the majority of it is still suck. I could see myself using the Genius playlister, I like the grid approach, and I still love controller, but I'm not switching. Until they fix the pre-existing baseline issues, I'm sticking with my Foobar2k.









FriendFeed
Twitter
Last.fm
Google Reader